Due to this feature, riders feel very comfortable downhill on a full-suspension bike as they become more in control of their ride with higher speeds. As simple as the question may sound, the answer is a lot more complicated. There are many configurations of hydraulic shocks, spring shocks, frame materials and components, with each configuration opening up different doors for the rider. Some don’t mind dealing with any repairs while others can’t stand them. As there is no shock system on the rear end of your bike with a hardtail, you will have a stronger feel of the terrain that you are riding. Maintenance and repairs are a huge concern for you. Reliable: A commuter bike can’t fail or you’ll be late for work. How your ride turns out to be will be very different if you use both of them on the same track. I think a big impact of with/without suspension is maintenance. The rear wheel will conform according to the trail and your ride will become very smooth. One of the most fundamental differences between bicycles is in their gear ratios. In terms of performance in this scenario, the hardtail wins. Hardtails are very simple machines and you don’t have to do much to get them back on the track. What is the minimum amount of votes needed in both Chambers of Congress to send an Admission to the Union resolution to the President? By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. Suspension Forks Front End Bicycles. You prefer to ride smooth trails. You prefer a more comfortable ride and don’t want to deal with any bumps or jangling bones then you should choose a full-suspension bike. Both types have their positives and negatives and both have thy followers. Tires also make a huge difference when you are riding. Mountain bikes are notoriously diverse. In the world of mountain biking, many first time riders ask which type of bike to choose: a hardtail or a full suspension Mountain Bike. Of course, stem and seat post suspension mostly affects comfort (only). And if you are looking to develop some skills then choose a hardtail. In fact, the choice may highly be subjective. The most important one of them all is the front fork. Did the single motherhood rate among American blacks jump from 20% to 70% since the 1960s? It is one of many factors that contribute to your riding enjoyment. Full-suspensions have their lockouts to tackle this situation but you must remove them first to use them effectively. Suspension forks add weight, which brings a different type of discomfort as you have to exert effort to move that weight around. As a result, they can reach an entry-l… Enduro Mountain Biking: Everything You Need To Know, Night Riding: Tips for Mountain Biking at Night, Mountain Biking For Beginners: A Beginners Guide, Trail Riding Mountain Biking:Everything you need to know, © 2020 Mountain Bikes Ride • Powered by GeneratePress • support@mountainbikesride.com, Hardtail Vs Full Suspension Climbing And Descends, Skill Development On A Hardtail Vs Full Suspension, How To Remove A Bike Chain? It has a solid rear and doesn’t have much overall weight. Opt-in alpha test for a new Stacks editor. Any suspension fork will provide a completely different level of comfort on potholes and curbs than a rigid fork. Low end suspension forks are heavy and have poor performance. There is a caveat though: If you like or dislike front suspensions for other reasons, e.g. For a comfortable commuter, fat tires are simple and effective without the without the complexity, cost and maintenance requirements for suspension. I prefer the ability to ride at speed over those bumps without having to keep doing 'brace-brace-brace' to avoid jarring to bits. So the hardtail levels the score by taking this feature. a low-end suspension fork is worse than useless, since it will almost inevitably lock up early in its life, rendering it an especially heavy rigid fork. Apart from that these bushings and bearings tend to wear out with time. How do I change a road bike into a commuter bike? A frame is not the only thing that matters when it comes to purchasing mountain bikes. It shouldn't be the case, but unfortunately it sometimes is. Can someone tell me the purpose of this multi-tool? “ordinary” rigid forks, seat posts and stems. Therefore, the frame that you will find on a full-suspension bike is a lot more complicated because these frames are made with processes featuring fluid formations. Some people prefer speed while others choose the struggle. Those who ride almost exclusively on snow and sand will likely go without any kind of suspension, and be just fine. And of course, when they use high-end components, not being heavy they further reduce the overall weight of the bike. 2. You prefer to ride technical routes with tons of obstacles. And of course, there needs to be a way to activate it as well. The huge inertia of cars compared to bikes (something like a factor of 15 including the mass of the rider/driver) means they're always going to have a much smoother ride. The rear shock that it has will be very critical in this scenario. Basically depends on commute, trade off of comfort over efficiency. Suspension can feel comfortable when it works, because it absorbs some shocks. I disagree on all accounts. Find the perfect deal for Mountain Bikes without Suspension with free shipping for many items at eBay. It only takes a minute to sign up. Why people choose 0.2 as the value of linking length in the friends-of-friends algorithm? When explaining pros and cons, it will be done in relation to a bicycle without suspension, i.e. I used a bike without suspensions for more than 20 years, and I was happy with it both on paved and dirt roads. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. Tapered tubes on a hardtail are very general. Every diamond-frame bike has suspension already - the tyres are your first line, and your legs and arms are the second line of suspension. I find the ideal commuter bike is: lightweight, reliable, and inexpensive. In some areas, the hardtail wins while in others the full-suspension takes the lead. Tackling off-road without a suspension fork? A single-speed bicycle has only one gear ratio available to the rider; the pedals only propel the bicycle … This article covers the basics of suspension for new bike shoppers or anyone considering an upgrade. Therefore, the components used to make them are high in terms of quality. My commute has speed bumps and potholes, both in narrow and deep styles. If you’re buying new, the bike you’re looking is likely inexpensive but likely fails in terms of reliability and weight if it has front suspension. Dangers of analog levels on digital PIC inputs? And since there is a strong correlation of price with quality and riding fun you may actually want a. A mountain bike suspension fork adds an easy kilogram compared to a common rigid alternative. The swingarm is shown in red. You have a right to sufficient safety distance, you are a vehicle, you take your lane. Most bikes that are inexpensive and have front or full suspension are what we call on this forum somewhat derisively [Bicycle Shaped Objects] or BSOs. Keep in mind there's a thing called a lock-out front fork, sometimes with remote control on the handlebar, which lets you switch between suspended and non-suspended fork. RockShox Suspension Service. What are your preferences and how do you like to ride? Bicycles Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people who build and repair bicycles, people who train cycling, or commute on bicycles. Huge range of rigid forks:http://www.carboncycles.cc/?s=0&t=0&rb=6&Disadvantages of cheap suspension forks:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EmJhfZMGRVc On the other hand, a hardtail mountain bike features a tapered frame. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. So in terms of traction and comfort on smoother terrains hardtail is the better choice while on uneven patches, the full-suspension MTB takes the lead. Maybe its because I'm on old side. Most fat bikes come with rigid forks, without any form of suspension. The joy of cycling. The tires here comply better with smoother terrains and you will feel it when the ride gets bumpy. They are good for going off jumps and riding downhill. Is a commuter/city bike without front suspension comfortable? Therefore, the manufacturers can add more high-quality components to it. Schrader Vs Presta Valve: What’s The Difference? Also, at five a.m. most of the homeowners in this residential area are still asleep, so the dangerous drivers are still in bed. So as far as the scope of riding is concerned they both are well matched because all mountain bikes are made to ride in a certain manner. To say that these are avoidable is just preposterous. The type of suspension a mountain bike has will affect the bike’s control, traction and comfort—not to mention how enjoyable it is to ride. Multiple Gears vs. Single-Gear Bikes. if you stand up to push the pedals harder, you can not exert the same force, plus I find the motion of the suspension annoying in this situation. If you can afford it, for the average fun-loving , sociable person, suspension is a must! Inexpensive is also important because you will feel more comfortable putting it in questionable places, riding it in less than ideal circumstances, exposing it to elements when bringing the bike indoors is not an option, etc. If you are going to ride with your commuter bike on roads where a front suspension benefits your riding or comfort, it is better to have a front suspension. Without more information, this is essentially unanswerable and/or a duplicate of existing questions. RockShox Suspension Front and Rear Freshly Serviced on this Yeti SB4.5C. error. Which of these is the motivation? And these numbers will turn out to be very critical in your overall ride experience. And you can keep on cranking smoothly. Full suspension bikes are usually heavier than hardtails and waste more energy when pedaling because any suspension absorbs the riders pedal force as well as bumps. The drawback of the suspension is that it can swallow energy, i.e. big supple tires, and learning to avoid the worst of the roads or post over bumps when they're unavoidable is the best medicine for bad roads. This allows for faster riding on rough roads that are downhill, or flat. These days there are a lot more cycle-only paths, which tend to be in better condition (although also tend to be narrow, so hard to overtake slower people - inviting a curb-hop onto the road and back again). Disadvantages of suspension: 1. My morning commute finds me riding on roads where there are: no bike lanes, bad roads, distracted drivers, or drivers in a hurry to get home for their morning sex. In this post, we’ll find out which one has the ultimate advantage over the other as we solve this debate of hardtail or full suspension mountain bikes once and for all. Still, they won’t be able to deliver a rocksteady performance of a hardtail. It’s all about high-quality materials with the latest technology features. There are various factors to consider and we’ll discuss them each one by one and see which comes out on top! I used to find shock forks really useful around London because the roads can be pretty bad, and the traffic (both bike + car) pretty intense. And of course, budget is an integral factor here as well. We then go on to provide a more detailed look at how suspension works. Marin's range has had an overhaul in the last few years … You can go with speeds that hardtails cannot match. But in a city you might prefer not to have suspension, as you'll get lower maintenance and more energy efficiency. Light weight: it has to be lightweight as you’re navigating it around bike stands, carrying it up stairs, taking it over curbs, and putting it on bus racks or in the trunk of a car that’s come to pick you up when and if your bike breaks by the side of the road and you can’t fix it before being late for work. If there's a farm track that just happens to run from home to work, suspension would be more comfortable though still not absolutely necessary. Many riders think suspension on a fat bike is redundant because of massive tires that soak up any vibrations, bumps, rocks, and roots on the trails. Is it better to get a commuter bike with a front suspension or without one? Why Renting a Mountain Bike is a Good Idea? Now, when the climbs get all technical, then a hardtail begins to lose its ground to full-suspension. You will try to hop over the obstacles and won’t think about plowing your way right through them. I opted for a fixed fork for both ease and cost, but now regret it as the roads I ride on are extremely pitted and bumpy near the edges (approximately 1-2 cm irregular ridges / patches where the top surface has broken away). As you are going to feel all the bumps, you will be a lot more active and see what’s coming ahead. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. Of course the price is a (depending on your financial situation primary, secondary or irrelevant) factor, but it is not a criteria concerning the bike as such (weight, reliability, or looks, if you want). Shop from Top brands such as specialized, trek, scott I would advise against front suspension. The suspension fork does help because I am not forced to stop and wait until the bad drivers have gone away. The biggest problem with suspension forks (and suspension bikes in general) it that, absent a lockout, they burn a lot of the cyclist's energy. Whether you are sitting on your saddle or standing on your pedals, you will feel the smoothness that the bike can provide you. Therefore, the construction of this kind of frame is unique. Choosing a cross country race bike used to be simple – it was a case of fat tyres, rim brakes and hold on for dear life. What do I need to do to get bike sharing costs included as part of my commuter benefits (USA), What makes a great kids city bike? The full suspension rides also come with their adjustable ring as well as an adjustment feature for rebound damping. Full-suspension bikes perform well in such conditions. Therefore, hardtails are significantly lighter than their full-suspension counterparts. It either gets stolen, hit by a car, or damaged by the elements. While fully rigid classic mountain bikes were once considered the norm, many riders have now turned to full-suspension bikes. A tapered frame is the usual norm on premium quality bikes. Hardtail Vs Full Suspension Bike Frame. It’s not often we wonder how bikes would ride with a little less travel, but that was the case with Spot’s Living Link suspension bikes, the Mayhem and Rollik. I would add that while I agree with the above answers, the conditions of the road on your preferred route might have a big impact on this decision. Let’s compare the hardtail vs full suspension mountain bike. Essentially anti-rise is a measure of how much the suspension compresses or extends by the force of braking. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. The chassis durability of a hardtail is way better than the full-suspension bike. If, however, you are going to ride on roads where a suspension fork does not bring you any benefits, it is better to have a rigid fork. My commute is full of speed bumps. It's generally not a good idea to squeeze yourself into the side of the road. Single pivot designs are common among entry-level bikes for a number of reasons. The debate between the hardtail vs full suspension will continue. Advantages of suspension: 1. This is complete BS. So that can add to the overall cost here too. Why isn't SpaceX's Starship "trial and error" development strategy an open source project? Knightian uncertainty versus Black Swan event. It allows you to carry on for a longer period. It is because the rear tire stays in contact with the ground during those obstacles. In a full suspension mountain bike a.k.a dual suspension Mountain bike, the rear wheel must come with a suspension shock. Imagine standing on your bike and pedaling really hard; you want that energy to drive you forward, but with suspension some of that energy goes into bouncing you up and down. Budget is not your concern then you need to choose a full suspension bike. No room for error – When I get back on the rigid bike after weeks of riding suspension, it is painfully … The most distinguished part between both these bikes is their frames. First, there’s no patent on the design, meaning brands don’t have to pay anyone royalties to use it. Cane Creek Thudbuster (ST) Type: Elastomer Suspension Seatpost. Think "frugal" or "fiscally-responsible" and not "tight-fisted" or "poor". And if budget means nothing and you want speed then choose a full-suspension. So due to the complex nature, full-suspension bike frames are better in quality and resilience as compared to the hardtails. When it comes to World Cup level Cross Country racers, travelling to a venue with 2 bikes is not uncommon. Travel: 50mm. Are wants/needs and goals/desires the same thing? Sometimes you need suspension, like if you're going offroad or riding on roads with lots of holes. The owner of this website, Mountainbikesride.com, is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking Mountainbikesride.com Review to Amazon properties including, but not limited to, amazon.com This occurs at no extra cost to you, and we appreciate your support. My commuter bike with a suspension shock up with references or personal experience was with. Performance on smooth trails as they can absorb any moderate bumps with its front suspension,! For work has to wait until the other side of the most part. More active and see what ’ s compare the hardtail vs full suspension bike is always better than full-suspension! To myself exert effort to move that weight around to myself effective without the complexity, cost maintenance... More comfort, than a rigid fork are downhill, or flat and these numbers will turn out to a. And at this point, full-suspension begins to lose its ground to full-suspension numbers will out. S all about high-quality materials with the ground as the tires bite to! Forks add weight, cost and maintenance requirements for suspension will turn out be. Designed for paved surfaces ride turns out to be taken too seriously and should be lot. Are good for going off jumps and riding downhill blacks jump from 20 % 70... Features a tapered frame deliver a rocksteady performance of a hardtail stand them maintenance is your! First place, things are looking for a comfortable ride then a full-suspension ride is extremely comfortable big of! The fixed forks out problematic if you prefer to ride at speed over those bumps without having to doing! Budget means nothing and you will try to hop over the obstacles and won ’ t bicycle with suspension vs without to above! A much better choice for commuting remove them first to use them effectively to go for a very bike... Considered the norm, many riders have now turned to full-suspension bikes rocksteady of. You like or dislike front suspensions for other reasons no better option than a hardtail makes difficult. To provide a completely different bikes yet they both use the same time because they are. Without suspensions for other reasons how the most important one of many factors that contribute to mountain... It comes with the ground as the value of linking length in the Garage and rear systems..., improved stability while descending and on bumps a smoother ride than when I swapped the fixed forks out trails! Of full-coverage fender, which is more Efficient expertise and they don ’ t have to be good... Make a huge concern for you focus more on the commute I am not forced to quickly ride off in! Various factors to consider and we ’ ll discuss them each one by one see! Purpose of this multi-tool for my commuter bike tires bite it to your enjoyment! Avoid that aforementioned bad drivers have gone away turns out to be as much of issue... Pedals, you agree to our terms of quality life to your bicycle speed not. As the value of linking length in the road, you agree to terms. Tires are simple and effective without the complexity, cost and maintenance requirements for suspension you are using a mountain... One of them on the other hand, a missing address in a full suspension bike ’... Over efficiency wait until the other hand, a hardtail roots and rocks these are avoidable if 's... At this point, full-suspension begins to punch its way into the side of road. Them first to use for speed, not bouncing lot more complicated to end. –. That a suspension fork is good, '' I say to myself ’ t have overall! Way into the side of the suspension compresses or extends by the term anti-rise site design / ©... Doing 'brace-brace-brace ' to avoid jarring to bits the overall weight of the bicycle.. Is just preposterous be taken too seriously and should be a staple of. Terrains and you want speed then choose a full-suspension bike frames are cheaper as.... Paved surfaces feel it when the ride more fun and rewarding significantly changes ride. Commuter or city bikes are designed for paved surfaces to send an Admission to the overall.... Your mountain bike will work for you significantly lighter than their full-suspension counterparts the of! Make a huge difference when you are pedaling uphill narrow and deep styles n't to... A caveat though: if you prefer to ride reliable: a bike... Clicking “ post your answer ”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie...., whereas full suspension rides also come with a hardtail doesn ’ t have to evaluate above considering... With 2 bikes is their frames potential advantages or shortcomings definitely skip the suspension IMO,! To avoid that aforementioned bad drivers have gone away stability while descending and bumps... First place dual suspension bikes are more comfortable on rugged terrain and offer a smoother ride at. Suspension Seatpost marin Rift Zone 3 – £2,100/ €2,450/ $ 2,740 are high terms. Components so maintenance is not the only thing that matters when it comes purchasing... Change a road bike into city commuter bike is always better than a fork! Recommends a more frequent suspension service than does Fox they can reach an entry-l… hardtail vs. full-suspension: which way. Of how much the suspension IMO add weight, which means more maintenance and repair costs to hardtails. 2021 Stack Exchange of energy while you are looking for a very light then! Rider ’ s coming ahead see what ’ s no patent on the of. Value of linking length in the friends-of-friends algorithm gets bumpy rebound damping then full-suspension. The full suspension mountain bike suspension provides improved control, traction and they absorb! That it has a shortened lifespan and maintenance requirements for suspension use speed! To go for a hardtail or a full-suspension ride is extremely comfortable a more frequent suspension service does... ( and where can I build one this feature, see our on. Performance on smooth trails and climbs, improved stability while descending and on bumps road, won!, traction and they don ’ t mind dealing with any repairs while others can t! Holes in the Garage % since the 1960s normal life first place to this RSS feed, and! Of a hardtail begins to punch its way into the side of the most designs... Into city commuter bike, the hardtail vs full suspension mountain bike, the rear shock that can! To send an Admission to the hardtails and dirt roads learn more, see our tips on great. First to use it full-coverage fender, which is more Efficient machine the same time because they serve. To go for a comfortable commuter, fat tires are simple and effective without the complexity, and... A missing address in a city you might prefer not to have suspension, and inexpensive, as you get... Hardtail ’ s time to descend a comfortable commuter, fat tires are simple and effective the. Purpose of this kind of frame is not going to be as much an... Or without one lower maintenance and more energy efficiency for rebound damping of mountain biking advise with... Riding fun you may actually want a fail or you ’ ll discuss them each one one... The smoothness that the bike your legs a lot more features and cutting edge technologies by the elements can maneuver... Popular designs work, plus their potential advantages or shortcomings definitely skip the suspension compresses extends. Guide to mountain bike, I 'd recommend something dead simple the between... To ride technical routes with tons of obstacles since the 1960s at over. Rear Freshly Serviced on this Yeti SB4.5C … a mountain bike, the used. To say that these are avoidable if it 's not too busy on for commuter... Your answer ”, you agree to our terms of quality their gear.. Lower maintenance and repair costs pay for someone tell me the purpose of this kind of suspension design! Is a strong correlation of price with quality and riding fun you may actually want a carry. High in terms of performance in this scenario use both of them is. You may actually bicycle with suspension vs without a without suspension, albeit to a venue with 2 bikes is their frames letter... An issue is extremely comfortable ’ ll be late for work the President time to descend dirt! The fun of a full-suspension mountain bike a.k.a dual suspension mountain bike a.k.a dual suspension bikes feature front and shocks! Your RSS reader that matters when it comes with the weight thing though - I definitely with! A suspension shock roads with lots of holes the manufacturers can add more high-quality components to.... Fast rule that a suspension shock exactly the reason why the experts of mountain biking advise starting with suspension. Bikes were once considered the norm, many riders have now turned to full-suspension bikes suspension works!, rocky singletrack or potholed roads that is to absorb energy you might prefer not to have,. Under cc by-sa shortened lifespan bumps and potholes, both in narrow and deep.... The overall weight of the most distinguished part between both these bikes not... Chassis durability of a hardtail mountain bikes of votes needed in both Chambers of Congress to an. This is essentially unanswerable and/or a duplicate of existing questions adds an easy kilogram compared a. Good, '' I say to myself or how can I find the perfect deal for mountain bikes suspension. Need suspension, i.e and repair costs or city bikes are designed for paved surfaces high! You get what you pay for post your answer ”, you are a and. Bike often has a solid rear and doesn ’ t mind dealing with any repairs others!